Thinking about renting in Cheyenne? Whether you're relocating for work, just moved to town, or need a stepping stone before buying, the rental scene here has its own unique rhythm.

Here’s what you really need to know before jumping into a lease in the Magic City of the Plains.

Rental Guide

The Truth About Renting in Cheyenne

What You Need to Know Before Signing a Lease

1. Inventory is Tight — Act Fast

Cheyenne isn’t a big city, and while it’s growing, our rental inventory is limited—especially during the summer months or when military families are transferring in or out. Desirable properties (especially those near FE Warren AFB, downtown, or in newer subdivisions) go quickly.

Tip from Lexi: If you see something you love, don’t wait. Be ready with your paperwork and references!

2. Pricing is All About Location

In Cheyenne, proximity matters. Want to be near downtown’s charm, Frontier Mall, or high-ranking schools? Expect to pay a bit more. On the flip side, neighborhoods further out often offer more space and a quieter lifestyle at a better price point

3. Most Rentals Are Managed by Property Management Companies

Unlike other markets where you may rent directly from a homeowner, Cheyenne’s rentals are often handled by professional property managers. This can be a good thing—it adds structure and consistency—but also means stricter screening and lease terms.

4. Pets? Not Always Easy

Pet-friendly rentals are limited. If you’ve got a furry friend (especially a larger dog), be prepared to pay pet deposits and possibly a monthly pet rent. Some properties have strict breed restrictions too.

5. Not All Rentals Are Listed on Zillow

While Zillow and Apartments.com can be a good start, many local management companies post listings on their own websites or even on Facebook. Some solid rentals never make it to national sites.

6. Thinking About Buying Instead?

With rent prices rising and inventory tight, it might be the right time to crunch the numbers. If you’re planning to stay in Cheyenne for a few years, owning could be the smarter move.

I offer free home valuations and strategy calls to help renters figure out if homeownership is the right next step.

Looking for a Place in Cheyenne? Here's How to Find Short-Term or Long-Term Rentals

  • Local Property Management Companies

    Most long-term rentals in Cheyenne are handled by professional property managers. These companies often have listings that aren’t posted on national sites.

    Pro Tip: Visit their websites directly and sign up for listing alerts.

  • Facebook Marketplace & Local Groups

    Facebook Marketplace is a goldmine for both short-term and long-term rentals, especially private landlord listings. You can also join local housing groups like:

    Cheyenne WY Rental Properties

    Cheyenne Wyoming Rentals

    Cheyenne Wyoming-OurHouseForRent Home rentals

    Be cautious of scams—never send money before seeing a place in person or verifying the property.

  • Zillow, Apartments.com & HotPads

    These national sites are great for long-term rental searches, especially for apartments or multi-unit properties. You can filter by price, pet-friendliness, and lease terms.

    However, not all Cheyenne rentals make it to these platforms—especially those managed locally—so they should be part of your strategy, not your only source.

  • Airbnb & Furnished Finder

    These are especially helpful for:

    Military families in transition

    Traveling nurses

    Newcomers who want to test the area before buying.

    Many Airbnb hosts are open to longer stays and may offer discounts—just message them directly!

DISCLAIMER

Lexi Leckemby and her team are not rental agents and do not manage rental properties. This rental guide is provided as a helpful resource only. For specific rental inquiries, please contact local property management companies directly.

Moving to Cheyenne?
Start smart with the Cheyenne Resource Hub — your go-to guide for all things local!


From finding rentals and setting up utilities to discovering must-know tips about neighborhoods, schools, and services — everything you need is right here.

Move Smarter with the Cheyenne Resource Hub